Concepts
Ethics, law & frameworks/Principles & law · Framework

Four principles of medical ethics

What it means

Beauchamp & Childress's framework: AUTONOMY (respect the patient's right to make their own informed decisions), BENEFICENCE (act in the patient's interest/do good), NON-MALEFICENCE (avoid/minimise harm — 'first do no harm'), and JUSTICE (fairness in distribution of resources and treatment). Most ethical dilemmas are analysed by weighing these, which often conflict.

Worked example

Respecting a Jehovah's Witness's refusal of blood (autonomy) over the team's wish to transfuse (beneficence) — autonomy of a capacitous adult prevails.

In the exam

A team analyses a dilemma by weighing the patient's right to choose against their wish to do good, avoid harm, and use resources fairly.

What settles it

For a CAPACITOUS adult, autonomy generally trumps beneficence — you cannot treat against a valid refusal even to save life.

Classically confused with

GMC Good Medical Practice / duties of a doctor

Source: Beauchamp & Childress